Diamond Tiara is Hanging Over a Cliff...

[Fractured 2,684]

And you have the chance to save her.
How and why doesn't matter, but she's hanging from a large machine that will drop her off the cliff in three minutes. To save her, you have to push a red button. The button is wired to severely shock whoever pushes it. You have a 60% chance of permanently losing use of the hand that pushes it.
There's also a yellow button on the same panel. If you push it, you will be magically teleported back to your home. Your mind will be wiped, and you'll be made to think you just woke up; you'll forget this ever happened.
Diamond Tiara swears if you let her go, she'll change her attitude. There's no real incentive to believe her, and no worldly prize for saving her. There's also nobody up here but you and her. With all this in mind...
Which button would you push?

[Banul 3,831]

Push red with the left hand, don't use it for shit anyway.

 

Diamond Tiara is a bully, but shes also super young. I remember being a bit of a bully when I was young too, after spending a year as one of the "popular" kids. Shes got her whole life ahead of her, she can learn the error of her ways. Even then, I don't think being a person being a bully is justification for letting them die when you could have saved them.

Edited September 6, 2014 by Banul

[M'aiq the Liar 5,804]

Well, I don't need my left hand. And with magic I can always order a really badass replacement.

 

Diamond Tiara may be a bully, but she is a child. She has time to grow as a person and perhaps a near encounter with death will allow her to change her ways.

 

 

And besides, I always have my phone on me, and she is an earth pony. I would record me saving her, take the evidence to her dad and claim my reward. I'm sure that with phyiscal proof,validated by the princess of friendship herself either a reward or a seat amongst the council of friendship is in my future.

[GGG 176]

uh...what do you mean? i dont remember anything about diamond tiara hanging from no cliff

[Ruddboy Olaf 10,628]

I'd push the red button,but I wouldn't do it with my hand. I would push it with my foot.

 

The rubber of my shoe would prevent shock.

[Zekromic 1,054]

risking my hand is high, but having your conscience damaged is worse. Even though I won't remember anything if I press the yellow button, nothing will stop fate to somehow make me guilty, either by subconscious, or I'll find out somehow. Besides, she's a simple third class bully, not enough to let her die, besides, she's a child, she will change, and I don't expect her to get worse than that when she grows up in case she doesn't improve 

[rarity1 461]

I'd wait until she falls to her death before I push the yellow button.

Edited September 6, 2014 by Synyster

[Buck Testa 5,505]

Id push The red with my right hand (Im a lefty) no kid should have to die cause you find their personality a bit grating. Spoiled brat or not Id save her.

[Abia 258]

Red. One hand is a small price to pay for a life, and it's bo guarantee that I would lose the hand, anyway. I don't dislike Diamond Tiara; I've seen worse bullies and she still has time to mature.

[DJShy 873]

Push red with the left hand, don't use it for shit anyway.

 

Diamond Tiara is a bully, but shes also super young. I remember being a bit of a bully when I was young too, after spending a year as one of the "popular" kids. Shes got her whole life ahead of her, she can learn the error of her ways. Even then, I don't think being a person being a bully is justification for letting them die when you could have saved them.

 

Couldn't have said it better myself.

[ponylaces 1,870]

I'd probably press the red button and save her. Like Banul said, she's a bully, but she's still young.

 

Yeah, I sometimes acted like Diamond Tiara when I was little. People change. It's best not to hold grudges. I wouldn't like losing a hand though, but I don't really need a left hand.

Edited September 6, 2014 by PonyLaces

[Away 2,077]

I'd use a stick or some other object to push the red button. If not, oh well ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

[Hive King 2,001]

Was this inspired by Saw? Anyway, I cheat the test by flinging a rock at the red button. Otherwise, I think I'd still pick red button. Chances are I'd ask for a reward

[Art Thief 215]

I think this gif holds the answer to this question. 

[ghostfacekiller39 23,860]

Red. DT is a little bitch, but I'd rather have my hand get permanently damaged than someone lose their lives when I could've saved them.

[Celtore 2,770]

I'd push the red button (and according to random.org, my hand made it out.)

 

I'm a bit of a sap, I wouldn't be able to ignore or walk away from anyone hanging over a cliff. Even if I wouldn't remember pushing the yellow button, it just wouldn't be right. I would consider the yellow button if the repercussion involved saws, knives and blades. Being injured and/or killed by those types of tools is my biggest fear and cowardice would win over conscience.

[Eliash147 159]

I Would push the red button with my left hand

She's just a kid she has plenty time to learn better and she shouldnt have to die for being a bitch

[A/H 81]

And you have the chance to save her.

How and why doesn't matter, but she's hanging from a large machine that will drop her off the cliff in three minutes. To save her, you have to push a red button. The button is wired to severely shock whoever pushes it. You have a 60% chance of permanently losing use of the hand that pushes it.

There's also a yellow button on the same panel. If you push it, you will be magically teleported back to your home. Your mind will be wiped, and you'll be made to think you just woke up; you'll forget this ever happened.

Diamond Tiara swears if you let her go, she'll change her attitude. There's no real incentive to believe her, and no worldly prize for saving her. There's also nobody up here but you and her. With all this in mind...

Which button would you push?

I would not risk losing any of my hands to save any fictional small witchcraft horse, especially worst-horse. Witchcraft is illegal here anyways. 

Edited September 6, 2014 by Aaliyah Haddad

[11th Doctor Whooves 794]

Save her of course.  She's a bully, but she doesn't deserve to die.  I'd push the button with my left hand, as others have said, since I'm right handed.  I'll just use that Magic Mirror Starswirl came up with to travel to the FMA universe and get some bad ass automail.

[Odyssey 5,716]

I would press the red button. Just because Diamond Tiara is a bully doesn't mean she deserves to suffer from a terrible death. Honestly, if I pressed the yellow button instead, I would feel like a bully myself. It confuses me to see that people want DT dead just because of her childish actions.

 

I would press the button with my right hand, however, since I'm left handed.

Edited September 6, 2014 by Mienshao

[Ziggy + Angel + Rain 11,302]

If I push the button that saves her, I'm not doing it with either of my hands lol.  Losing a hand IS a big deal; I'm not even considering sacrificing a vital part of my body for someone unless I genuinely love them.  I don't love Diamond Tiara.  I'm sure there's some object nearby that won't readily conduct electricity.  Or hell, I could probably throw a rock at the button hard enough to depress it.  And why push the mind-wiping button at all?  I'd just stay in Equestria (assuming that's where I was).

[Celli 4,337]

I don't care if DT is a bully. She may be mean, but she doesn't deserve to die. The only thing she deserves is to be taught some serious lessons.

I use my right hand for pretty much everything anyway.

[LunaKaiba 30]

Normally i would help because i would never forget that i let somepony die!

But seeing i wouldn't even remember it all happened.... Yellow button it is!

Bye Diamond Tiara.

[User0815 264]

I'd push da red button cuz red my fav color

[WarriorShy 48]

Yellow, because you know, she is Diamond Fricking Tiara