Who's your favorite MLP analyst?

[Moved to Elsewhere 11,331]

Oh yeah here are analysts I'm subscribed to but mainly watch them on or off

ilovekimpossiblealot

Buc Brony

Drowing in Horeshoes 

 

ones I watch but I'm not subscribed to

Voice of Reason

Texeirax 

[Super Derpy 535]

Has to be VoiceOfReason. I've been watching him since he had like 800 or so subs and I think now he has 8,000 or so. Hes so great because hes not afraid to state his opinion, no matter what it is.

 

I also watch Digi sometimes and of course our MLP Forums resident Pink Mist! :3 Also I've been starting to watch Buc Brony recently. 

Edited February 4, 2014 by Super Derpy

[Moved to Elsewhere 11,331]

Oh and I forgot to mention Dr Wolf

[ShadowRose2k 271]

Gibbontake, Silverquill, Tom Oliver, Digibro, Ilikekimpossiblealot, PoetessMLP, I can't Decide!!!

Tom and Digi are the ones that started me watching the episode reviews.   But If I had to pick one, I'd say Silverquill Has been the most entertaining reviewer this season.

 

I often wonder If i should review stuff,  But I probly would like to give my opinions on the Toys mostly.

[Bucky McGillyCuddy 956]

He's a hippogriff actually.

Wow, I can't believe I never noticed the back legs haha. To busy enjoying the facial expressions I guess 

[FNGRpony 658]

Definitely Digi!

There's just something really adorable about the way he says and does things. I don't know what it is.

I don't mind if he gives a negative review, because i often felt the same way about the episode. Even when he gives a negative analysis to an episode i liked, I see no reason for him to avoid criticizing an episode if that's how he actually felt about it. What is he supposed to do, lie about how much he loved it?

Digi's a great deal deeper than "the voice" he puts on.

I find him fascinating.  I wish i could offer some solid insight by what i mean,  but poking around his pod casts, beyond the chear ful happy go lucky digi

there layers, and layers.

 

I couldn't begin to explain those layers

[Edgeworth1001 648]

Digibrony, Ink Rose, and Voice of Reason.

[RockinRarity 1,605]

Silver Quill!!!!

 

He is very funny and as of late his reviews have been the most balanced. He is honest about flaws in some episodes without sounding too jaded.

 

Digibrony used to appease me a lot but I agree that he has gotten a bit too negative for my taste. I think that he has started to take analyzing episodes too seriously and doesn't let flaws in episodes roll off his back. I respect his opinion to not like an episode and I did pretty much agree with his review of Daring Don't but I dunno, he admitted to possibly being jaded in his review of Pinkie Pride and I appreciated the things he said in that review. I just think that as of late he has forgotten what kind of show he is reviewing.

 

BronyCurious/Tommy Oliver is enjoyable to listen to for his Q&As. But I think like Digi he has also gotten a little jaded.

 

KimiSparkles is hilarious. I don't get around to watching her much but she is enjoyable.

 

I also like Dr. Wolf.

Edited February 7, 2014 by RockinRarity

[Celestial Wish 349]

Definitely Digibro. Persian Poetess. I'm actually new to the analysis group, so what are some other good analysts? 

[Courageous Thunder Dash 7,824]

Silver Quill! Not only does he analyze really well, but he adds humor to it!

[ReverseFaller 2,483]

Either Digi or Kimi Sparkle, as they win by default. (I don't watch very many analytical MLP videos on youtube.)

[Flamethrower 1]

This youtuber right here: Star Swirl

 

He's awesome. I like him

[Celli 4,338]

My favorites would have to be Drwolf, MysteriousMrEnter, Silver Quill, and more recently Gibbontake. I used to like Digi, but now, well, I just don't really like him anymore. I liked when he did headcanons and random analysis. Oh I also like Bronycurious. Antony C if he updated more often. And Voice of Reason is probably my least favorite. When he hates an episode or something like FiW, I feel he overreacts a bit. I liked Paleosteno, but Shout! factory happened.

[Wind Chaser 4,768]

BronyCurious/Tommy Oliver, Digibrony, Dr Wolf, Voice of Reason, Strebiskunk, Brawny Buck/Brony Debates, AnY Pony, Mr Enter, Antony C, GoldenFox. In that order.

 

I watch some of the others occasionally.

Edited February 23, 2014 by pegasusexpress2010

[King Sejong 859]

   For reviewers, I love Joshscorcher, from F.O.B. Equestria, he is one of the few military bronies who is an minor internet celebrity, his style is pretty close to the Nostalgia Critic, he also had a podcast with Doug Walker himself, so that was sheer awesome to watch.

 

   For an analysis, I love Kimi Sparkle and Silver Quill, they are both light hearted and have humorous moments, they get down to the details, but not too deeply as to spoil the fun from the episode, in addition I like Silver Quill's voice, it's the sort of suave, sophisticated vocals, and I love his review of "Bats". Now I do watch Digibro, Bronycurious, Buc Brony, Voice of Reason and Mysterious Mr. Enter, they are quite good with analysis, and I like what they have to say, but sometimes they get too detailed, and leave the humour to the background, also they sometimes ramble, and in a video that is not wise to go on too long, you could lose the audience interest, still I listen to their opinions, then I move on to Josh, Silver Quill and Kimi Sparkle to balance the serious with the entertaining.  

[~Silver Essence~ 2,625]

Josh Scorcher, as his points are quick and very informative.

 

Tommy Oliver for his branched out reviews on the series in general.

 

ANY pony for his top 5's yay's and neigh's of the newest episodes.

 

There's a few more, but I usually keep in track with these three in general.

[Virgil 685]

Antony C by far is my favorite, because he honestly impressed upon and showed me that one can analyise modern day media in an objective fashion, yet still potentially enjoy it ( example: he did do a very critical review of "A Canterlot Wedding" pointing out some major flaws, but has said in a podcast or something that he doesn't hate the episode ). Sounds like I'm being a bit overzealous or something I know; but that last individual I "came into contact with" that held such a high view of media (especially in regards to things aimed at children ) was C. S. Lewis, of whom I'm even more indebted to. And even though Antony doesn't do many straight analysis videos for MLP, when he does do one, you can't look at episode the same way again.

My second choice and someone who does videos more regularly would be Silver Quil. He is very sharp in his analysis and is also very entertaining ( and he made a Digimon reference in one of his more recent vids which earns points with me automatically).

[Red Cedar 1,408]

Don't know that you'd call him an "analyst", but I stumbled across Jerry Peet's Youtube videos and just about died laughing at his episode reviews. The best two are "Lesson Zero in Three Minutes" and "Hearts and Hooves Day in Two Minutes".

[DND 2,355]

DigiBrony and ILoveKimPossibleALot.

 

Kim does a pretty fine job with it, and not to mention she's really funny with the cutscenes. She makes clever ideas as well.

 

When I want something a little more in depth though, DigiBrony's best for that. He makes really clever topics and sticks to canon through and through. His voice is something appealing to. It's clear and not too emotional. It shows that he's not getting his info from his gut.

[mars 4,862]

Digibrony introduced me to the world of pony analysts, so an honorable mention to him.

 

My favorites are Two Brothers B**** About Ponies and Silver Quill. Both are hilarious with unique art, opinions I usually agree with, and overall likability.

[Shift 4,272]

Kimi Sparkle, she is so amazing.

[_Kurtis 636]

My favorite?

I guess that would be ILoveKimPossibleAlot!  

Though some of her reviews/analyzing videos may be short, I still enjoy them~

I do like the others, but ILoveKimPossibleAlot is the one I go to for videos first.   

Edited March 15, 2014 by Sugar Rush

[Chuckles4lyfe 441]

My favorite analyst? Well, here is a list of analyzers that I'm currently subscribed to:

• TheMysteriousMrEnter
• DRWolf001
• FOBEquestria (Josh Scorcher)
• Tommy Oliver
• TBBBAP
• Digibro
• Antony C
• VoiceofReason
• MLP-Silver-Quill
• StupidPrivate913

If I can only pick 1 out of the 10 that I listed above, then I would have to go with TBBBAP, with a close 2nd from Silver Quill. With TBBBAP, I find the brothers have great chemistry with each other when they discuss the new episode, and lately each of their episodes have skyrocketed in production quality. I'm amazed at how quickly they've grown in such a short amount of time.

 

And just for fun, my least favorite of the 10 would probably be Digibro. I just find him irritating and unpleasant to listen to now. I subscribed to him back in early 2013 when the analysis community was still relatively small. He was what helped make the analysis community as popular as it is today. I used to enjoy his videos a lot but lately I feel like he's really out of it and just seems disinterested in the show now. I understand that he feels burnt out and wants to take his channel in a completely different direction. I just hope that he finds success in whatever he analyzes in the future.

[That 80s Pony 62]

Bronycurious and IloveKimPossibleAlot!

Those two are very funny and fun to watch.   

[DoubleRainbow_Dash 317]

My personal favorite is TheMysteriousMrEnter because I just enjoy his review style. I also enjoy his animated atrocities series. I'm don't really watch many others because I'm not terribly cinical about a kids show.