Scenario: Protecting the Mane 6

[AkiraLeeJounouchi 857]

1St Off I would try to calm fluttershy down(And me in the process cuz I'd be super excited that she's here). Explain to her that I'm not going to hurt her. And She can trust me.

2nd Is to try to get her down from the Living Room Chandelier. If it breaks not only will my mom kill me but she might call the TSPCA on Flutters.

3rd after getting her down I slowly start to explain our world to her.

4th of all I would tell her about MLPFiM and explain to her how this is the Main universe while her's is fiction. It will freak her out but it's best that she knows from the start everything. I will do my best to support her. 

5th of all I'll tell her that I am her No.1 Fan and would like to get a hug hrom her.

6th of all We try to find a way for she to go back home.

[Rainblow H. Ash 5,091]

If it was any of the Mane Six except for Rainbow Dash, I would calm them down by explaining that they probably accidentally entered another dimension because of a spell or because of a magic mirror, and assure them that I would help them discover a way back.

 

If it was Rainbow Dash... I'd crack open the Bacardi and we'd get smashed!

[Rainboom Dash 1,056]

If they just appeared like that I'd probably totally freak out, which wouldn't help them at all.

[Snow Frostflame 3,568]

I would have my jaw dropped and utter to myself svyatoye der'mo (holy shit) then I would ask her to take me to Equestria

[Justin_Case001 4,896]

The difference between reality and fantasy is that in fantasy, we can imagine all sorts of ways we would react to the impossible.  If a man came forward in our society and revealed that he was from the planet Krypton, we'd all like to think that he may be accepted, and that he would become and ideal of hope.  In reality, we all know what would happen.  If Man of Steel actually happened, actually happend, FOR REAL, the world would tear itself apart within 24 hours.  Every country on Earth would probably blindly launch every nuke they had.  It would be complete apocalypse.  It's a shame, really, but we know that's what would happen.  It's because we have a complex set of systems in our brain that distinguish reality from fantasy, and we can vividly imagine the impossible all day, and everything is cool as long as our brains know that reality is still what we expect it to be.

 

If an MLP pony appeared in our living rooms?  Our brains would explode.  Our brains would rail against it with every ounce of strength.  Our minds would determine that this is impossible, and therefore not real.  Our minds would probably go into a state of shock and prevent us from even seeing the phenomenon.  When presented with something that it deems itself unable to comprehend, the brain has a remarkable ability to shut out said thing, even to the point of hallucinating so that the person doesn't even perceive the phenomenon with their senses.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Somebody_Else%27s_Problem

 

In short, we'd all go cuckoo for coco puffs if this actually happened.  But I'd like to believe, I sorely, desperately want to believe, even need to believe, that if one of the mane six appeared in my living room, I would kneel down before her and say in the gentlest of voices, "It's okay, sweetheart.  I'm not going to hurt you.  You're safe here.  I promise.  I want to help you."

[joecal97 340]

1. Become friends

2. Defend them with your life

3. Have a laugh with them, share stories, ask questions ( you know, friend stuff)

4. Say tearful goodbyes as they are rescued.

5. Feel privileged to have met them

 

Ps. 4.5. Ask if you can go to Equestria with them

[boiteporte 591]

I would probably stop drinking, close my eyes and wait for this to go away.

 

If it turns out it is real, I would call the Police.

[SystemError514. 86]

Stare in surprize, then not know what to do for a while.

[Geek0zoid 1,468]

I hope the pony I see is AJ or Pinkie Pie, because if I were to take them out in public they'll look like normal equines. Anyways, first off, I would try to calm them down a bit, and try my best to make them feel safe in my home. I'd imagine they'd want to move around out in public, so I'd need to think of some sort of way to hide their wings or horn (If they have either) If I can just hide their uniqueness from the public eye for a bit, everything should be fine.

Then I'd only have to deal with normal pet stuff, only this pet has more personality.

[Will Guide 21,360]

"No Equestria Girls", huh? Well, if that hasn't happened, then in my mind Season 4 hasn't happened either. So let's put the possible scenarios involving Alicorn Twilight I have in mind right after Magical Mystery Cure. I'll give one scenario now and the other later.

 

Scenario 1: Twilight's Stages of Grief. The newly crowned Princess Twilight Sparkle would go through the stages of grief over the span of a week and I would have to help her through it! For this scenario, she can't use her magic (at first), despite looking like herself. 

 

Day 1: Denial: Twilight is trapped in my world and tries to deny every explanation I give her. Even with the fact that when I tried to put on an episode of FiM, the episode has "magically" changed so that the characters are like actors saying stuff like "Where's Twilight?" by the Mane 5, or "This is supposed to be where she defeats me" a confused Discord would say. Every episode would act as if though Twilight was there in the previous episodes doing what she's always done only to have her "disappeared" right before the episode in question began. 

 

Day 2: Anger: Twilight gets angry blaming me for "bringing her here". Despite her anger getting me angry as well, I would still hold my ground and onto the belief that I can help her.

 

Day 3: Bargaining: Twilight starts begging me to help her and even without it, I'd do everything I can to protect her.

 

Day 4: Guilt: Twilight would feel guilty for her anger towards me a few days ago. Of course I would forgive her.

 

Day 5: Depression: Twilight would spend the whole day crying in my room, fearing she may never get back. By the way, I picture that she would find my Spike doll and kept it close to her all day as the closest she has to feel her friends are there with her.

 

Day 6: Acceptance: Twilight accepts the apparent fact that she is trapped in our world and that she's willing to pass herself off as an unusual pet pony. I would still keep my promise to protect her whenever the need would arise. I would spend all of that day reading to her my favorite Disney stories.

 

Day 7: Hope: On the clear starry night of the seventh day, as I'm saying good night to Twilight, I would look up toward the night sky, see the shining stars and sing the song that would give Twilight the feeling of hope, Disney's "When You Wish Upon a Star". Then out of the sky, Princesses Celestia and Luna would appear. They would explain that ever since Twilight disappeared, everyone including the jerks and villains they could get in contact with all worked together to build enough magic to open the way home for Twilight. However, it'd turn out that the song sung by me in our world, restoring Twilight's hope in the process, was the last thing that was needed to open the "door" between worlds.

 

I would smile and tell Twilight that ever since she got here, I'd never gave up on the hope that Twilight would return home to Equestria. Even when Twilight gave up on her day of depression, I kept hoping for us all. Celestia would smile and give me the honorary-yet-treated-unofficially title of "Element of Hope". After they would have gone back to Equestria, all the episodes would be restored, as if nothing has happened. However, the next time I'd see the theme song, at the point where Spike sends the Picture of the Mane 6 to Celestia, a "real" letter would appear in my living room where I would open it and smile at the sight of the Mane 5 with Alicorn Twilight and Spike standing around a banner saying "Thank You, William"

Edited October 31, 2014 by WiiGuy2014

[kanashimi purinsesu 244]

Well the first thing that came to my mind was 'Road Trip'. Let's assume that Twilight just poofs into my presence since she's most likely testing a new teleport spell or something. I'd look at her with the eyes of a deer seeing traffic in during a street race. Then, I'd slowly reach out a hand so she'd freak out about my 'Claws' since she's only seen a hand like thing from spike. AND THEN...id just say "WOAH HOW'D YOU GET HERE WE BETTER DO SOME SMALL TALK SO WE CAN FIGURE THIS OUT!"

and from there she'd use her logical thinking and stuff. I'd take her to a library after painting her all brown and putting string around her head so her unicorn looks like cosplay making her look like a normal, earthly horse and then while I check out books about being human (is that a thing...?) we'd read them in some field with other horses so she can study them and see just how much she has in common with our earthly horses. Yep.

And id just ask her to use a memory lost spell on people that saw us like that flash thing in Men in Black XD

[Passion 3,484]

Meh, it all entirely depends on which one of mane 6 would that be.

 

The first reaction would probably be the same for me. "The hell...? I must be still sleeping./JESUS CHRIST WHAT THE- (scared)", then awkward silence and then probably typical "Where did you come from!?" followed by utter confusion and disbelief. And after some explanations, it would really depend on which one would it be.

 

1. Twilight: No big deal, probably the easiest one to handle. She'd probably understand the situation fairly quickly and would sit quiet until the rescue came. I could see her potentially creating a mess while trying to reverse the effects of whatever transferred her to our world, but that's about it.

 

2. Applejack: Second easy one, since she's extremely sensible. I believe she'd also fairly quickly understand her position and would just patiently sit around, just waiting passively.

 

3. Fluttershy: This is where things would become tricky. Getting Flutters to listen and gaining her trust at all would require a lot, a LOT of effort. Hell, it could even prove impossible for such a stranger in such a strange new world. I'd probably have to hide her somewhat against her will, hoping she wouldn't do something unreasonable.

 

4. Rainbow Dash: Whelp, the first few minutes would probably be spared on shouting on each other. It would be dam' stressful to me, and RD would for sure verbally assault anyone after such events. And even if things would somehow get sorted out, I cannot imagine keeping her locked up at all. It could prove quite impossible, in all honesty.

 

5. The toughest one... Rarity: Even though she trusts just about everyone, it would first require answering an endless avalanche of questions coming from her, I believe. But that wouldn't be THAT bad. The really, REALLY bad things would start to happen the longer she'd have to stay around. Idle. Without a target. Just waiting. Away from Sweetie and her friends. I honestly don't know if I'd survive the amount of drama and complaining she'd put me through. Just like DDogs...

 

6. Pinkie Pie: ... ... ... ... ...God help us all.

[Cirrus. 1,089]

Glad to see what you guys think. After seeing what you guys came up with, and thinking about it for a day, I think they actually would be more trusting after calming down. I actually think Fluttershy would be in a pretty good mood because she would get to meet a new "creature" that talks. I still think Pinkie would be hell (ADD being cooped up and bored) if it was her who showed up.

 

I think the situation would be kind of like the movie E.T. in my case. I wouldn't want anyone to find out besides maybe a few trusted friends and family because it could end up absolutely horrific for the pony if taken away by the government. They probably actually would be viewed/treated as an alien, since they would look pretty much like they do in the show- not like a "real" pony.

 

BTW- I can't believe that movie is actually 32 years old!

Edited November 22, 2014 by steve88

[PROJECT: Simon 3,954]

> My Little Dashie

 

/thread

 

...

 

Okay. I have no idea. I'd probably freak out a lot. And scream. And run away. Then I'd go back and glomp Rainbow Dash ^^

You made me cry again (MLD)

[Heinz 83]

would bro fist / bro hoof to show that we humans mean no harm

[cuteycindyhoney 13,307]

World as myth...

 

"Twilight, by any chance have you met a human named Lazarus Long? If not, I have a feeling we both soon will. I hope the back yard is big enough for Gay Deceiver to land in!" 

(You get a cookie if you know what I'm talking about!)

[Admiral Regulus 2,769]

Look, guys. I'm not too good with words, so Pinkie, why don't you go ahead and explain everything for me.

 

Edit: nevermind, I thought the question was if all the mane six appeared. In the case that it's just one, it would depend on which one it is.

Edited October 22, 2014 by Regulus

[An Unknown Pony. 370]

1.c'mere partner

2.ohai *insert mane 6 name here*,would you like to be my friend

3.calm down,equestria isn't the only place that you can live.

4.oh my god.*speechless*

Edited November 1, 2014 by Sir Daniew

[FluffyGoat13 375]

Because I have a weird thought process here is evrything i would do step by step:

 

1. Ask myself why all the weird sh@t happens to me.
2. Wait 10 seconds to see if anything is going to be said by mentioned pony(s)
3. Quickly find some cake.
4. Place cake on table. Still say nothing.
5. Point at cake.
6. Finally say "Okay now there is some cake; HOW THE F~#K DID YOU GET HERE!!"
7. Apologise for swearing.
8. Grab both my dogs and my cat and place them in front of Fluttershy (if she is there).
9. Tell them where they are, who i am, what i am, and say that i'll explain how i know their name(s) later.
10. Figure out how they got here.
11. Tell them: how i know their names, about the show, about the fandom.
12. Ask that when they figure out how to get back "Can you take me with you? Earth sucks."

[Ash Windheart 167]

Let's see if I saw Rainbow Dash in my house and she looked confused I would greet myself and then say she was 20% than anything in the world in 10 seconds flat. :3

[Pinkamena-Pills 6,839]

"So it is time then huh, Pinkie. Let's begin." 

[verycreativeusername 1,800]

I would act like I don't know *insert mane 6 character here* because I'm pretty sure it would be creepy to her that I know her since I'm not from Equestria or anything but I would try to calm her down and have her stay with me and most likely have her not be seen by other people. 

• I calm her down first
• Me: "Who are you and where are you from?"
• Mane 6 character introduces herself, where she's from, and stuff
• Me: "Well my name is *censored* and you're not in Equestria anymore. You're in Earth."
• I hang out with pony, talking about Earth, humans, myself, and more and introduce her to some stuff Earth has to offer.
• I keep her inside my house to keep her safe for most or all of the time unless I can find a secluded place to bring her to if that is what she wants. I'll explain why, if I need to.
• I'll try to help bring her back to Equestria if I can, and see if I come there too if I need to as long as I can come back. I do this just in case Celestia doesn't come back or doesn't come back soon and I wouldn't be sure.
• When Celestia comes back to bring the Mane 6 pony back, I will ask if I can come there too, but I would prefer if I can go to Equestria and back home whenever I wanted.

Edited November 1, 2014 by Blixhauq

[Vox 870]

"Well shoot, thanks, Obama"

[RAGESTAR 479]

Me: *stares* no...fucking...wa-

 

Rarity: *screams her head off and runs*

 

Me: WAIT!! I'm not gonna hurt you!! *runs around my house, chasing her, trying to calm her down*

 

*two hours later*

 

Me: now...*gasp for air* if your done...*gasp for air* screaming and running, I can try to straighten things out...

 

Rarity: *sitting on the edge of the couch, as far from me as possible* Hmph! Why, I'd never! I only stopped screaming because I didn't want to strain my voice, and I stopped running because I stubbed my hoof...because SOMEPONY chased me...*glares at me*

 

Me: *deadpan* I chased you because you ran from me, even though I didn't even do anything...

 

 

And it would pretty much continue with Rarity being overly dramatic, thinking I foalnapped her. Right up until I showed her MLP FIM on my TV, then shed freak out, thinking I'm some sort of stalker, and run away again. XD

[Castle_Cross 331]

Calm the hoof down!!! Look I've got Apple cider!!! You can have it if you calm down, look flutters a kittie!!! Calm down and let's talk!!