general media Scariest Creepypastas? (NOT for people easily scared)

[HecateSix 45]

Well, it's 3:00 here in Germany and I can't fall asleep. Too much pony on my mind.

Anyways, I have a question. Are there my creepypastas that kept you all awake at night?

[Blue Moon 6,341]

Yes. Basically any Creepypasta I read at night scares the @#$! out of me. But if I read them during the day, I am fine. I have a bad habit of reading Creepypasta late at night in the dark all alone and I always regret it. But I love horror so much!

[Алексей 110]

CreepyPastas don't usually have much of an effect on me. I haven't read  a whole lot of them, but most of the seemingly popular ones; Jeff the Killer, Slender Man, The Ticket Taker(or whatever it was), BEN, Smile.dog, etc.

 

However, SCP-106 and Smile.dog did freak me out a good bit. But, for Smile.dog, it was the image, not the actual CreepyPasta. For SCP-106, it was partially the CreepyPasta, but mostly what he was like in SCP CB. Gods, he was so damn freaky; he's probably the only thing that has ever truly kept me up at night due to fear...

[Megas 27,655]

BEN Drowned kept me up at night for a good week, I couldn't even sleep without seeing the bastard's creepy stare, whether it was in the dark or in my head

[Celtore 2,770]

I'm not really much of a creepy pasta reader, but I will admit that a few SCP entries have ocassionally kept me up at night. SCP-106 and 096 really creeped me out for a while.

[Windwaker 194]

Jeff the killer and Ben downed. Ok, not Jeff. I do have his face in my mind, but Ben only kept me awake for 1 night. I eventually went to sleep.

[Genepool 224]

Only recently heard of creepypastas, and don't really pay attention to them to be honest.  Think the creepiest one I heard was about a preview session between animators for a Spongebob Episode with the creepypasta titled Squidward's Suicide. 

Edited March 31, 2013 by Genepool

[Moog the Kvlt 1,460]

Well...I never got freaked out by any creepypasta, since they all are quiet generic and repetitive, though I remember when I was about 9 or 10 finding out about the Tails Doll, which scarred me for a couple of months until I got over it, I slept with a lamp on after that. Though now I look at a picture of the Tails Doll at midnight without any effect at all.

[~/XC- BRONY\~ 310]

Definetly abandoned by disney! that entire backstory of the actual park kept me obsessed with the pasta.

 

i wont go into the obvious one that keeps everyone awake the first time they read it *Cough* slender man *Cough*

[Orchid Briar 18]

Rugrats Theory. :/

I don't know if it really kept me up at night, but it definaty was disturbing. Even had a song that was inspired by it, which was sung by Vocaloids.

[Yes-Man 597]

Creepypastas are only scary the first or second time, then you begin to realize most of them are bad copies of one another.

On topic, any and all of them the first one or two times.

[TailsIsNotAlone 3,695]

Sure, it's happened to all of us. I cooked some spaghetti wrong one night and the indigestion kept me awake. Now that was some creepy pasta.

[Sunbro 4 Lyfe 939]

BLOOD! BLOOD EVERYWHERE! 

every. Gaming Pasta. EVER.

"Well I got this cartridge from ebay/ an old guy and it had no cover and loud noises and scares and BLOOD and can't turn game off cause IQ less than 4 and then Die of (insert method of stupid paranormal death here)!

[~Sole~ 852]

Creepypasta are only as scary as you imagine it. The way I stop getting paranoid and nervous after watching an especially scary story is by imagining what discord or the mane 6 would do to the antagonist (slendy, jeff the killer ect.) To defeat or stop them (troll and annoy in discords case). Jeff the killers story used to be really creepy to me, now I barely react to seeing him or reading about him. Sorry if this sounds off topic, just thought I would help give some of you tips on how to sleep soundly.

[Throwaway19573639385 764]

Oh you wanna have something that'll keep you awake forever? Sure! Easily done! Just read this little gem and I bet you don't even need to sleep anymore! Sleep is for the weak! God I'm never going to sleep now

 

http://creepypasta.wikia.com/wiki/The_Face_in_the_Middle_of_Dark

[Lewis the Brony 110]

Ghost Caught on Tape kept me awake.

 

Nah, just kidding, it isn't a creepypasta. Just a screamer video. Actually, none of the creepypastas actually affect my sleeping habits. Sure, I might stay up for a while but I go to sleep and don't skip a night or two.

[Prince Midnight 817]

SCP's keep me up sometimes, but its jeff the killer that has kept me up at night, all the damn time, and it dosent help that i like watching markiplier play scary games that have to do with the creepypastas

[TheSupremeLeaderOfChaos 1,206]

Autopilot. That was the name of the story. Even though it didn't keep me awake at night, (nothing can stop me from sleeping) it made me think. A lot. It wasn't particularly scary. It wasn't a monster story. It just made me realise how easily we forget things. And how that can lead to terrifying consequences.

 

Another Creepypasta, though I can't remember its title, scared the crud out of me. There was a doll, or face, or something, outside of the guy's window. It wouldn't stop smiling. When he tried to cover it with the blinds, it got angry and beat on the window, trying to break through it. So the man left the blinds open. He couldn't sleep because he knew it was watching him. The last paragraph went something like this.

 

That's why I'm writing this. To help keep my sanity. I can feel him. He's sitting right behind me. He's watching me type.

 

And it ended. Freaking scary stuff man. That didn't keep me awake either, but I can still remember my chills when I read that...

[Twiliscael 3,960]

I read those to go to sleep, no joke. Reading makes me tired and sometimes I'll read some random creepypasta before bed.

 

They're all so repetitive and rely on the same form of scares to try to freak you out... doesn't work on me.

[HecateSix 45]

BLOOD! BLOOD EVERYWHERE! 

every. Gaming Pasta. EVER.

"Well I got this cartridge from ebay/ an old guy and it had no cover and loud noises and scares and BLOOD and can't turn game off cause IQ less than 4 and then Die of (insert method of stupid paranormal death here)!

So true... So very very true. Most creepypastas in general are pretty repetitive and generic bu gaming pastas are the worst. Thankfully ther's still the occasional diamond in the rough.

[Moonlight Magician 494]

I myself find Abandoned by Disney and Jeff the Killer to be the most disturbing. Especially Jeff the Killer. That face will forever remain in my mind.

[Scootalove 10,689]

Not for people who are easily scared, huh? Hmm, maybe you will get over it and the creepypasta will fade away from your memory. I've read worse.

[Moonlight Magician 494]

Yeah. I don't find the face to be that scary anymore. It still makes me jump when I randomly find it on the internet though.

[Windseeker 546]

Just read Jeff the Killer, it isn't that scary...

 

The Russian Sleep Experiment, that's another story...

[Life Giver 1,063]

I start to read a few of these stories... most are a little creepy... well others not so...