Your thoughts on 'Cupcakes' Creepypasta?

[Shift 4,272]

No. I don't 'hate' it, I just think it's stupid somepony made something that grimdark come into the land of innocent, pretty ponies.

[bladereaper07 42]

M'eh, it's a typical gorefest, nothing too fancy. I guess it's OK in a morbid way... Although, if you want a great Creepypapta, read The Cough... It's short, sad, and intriguing

[Stratos 109]

When something tries so hard that it becomes a parody of itself, I tend to laugh.

 

Cupcakes: Not even creepy, obvious plot, trying so hard to shock with gore that it becomes so unrealistic as to become ironically funny.  Kind of like a guy who stuffs his underwear with rolled up socks and then tries to wear tight pants to show it off.  Not intentionally trying to be funny, a bit gross, but hilarious all the same.

[Apocalyptic_Unicorn 240]

As much as I love gore and dark stories/imagery in general, I really don't want to read about my favorite characters being killed in brutal ways.

[mycarhasaMoustache 449]

Never been a fan but Its mostly because I dont understand why anyone would find violently mutilating an adorable pony "entertaining" also the writing is for lack of a better term "shit" If it wasn't so messed up I would have said it had been written by someone under the age of 10.

[Blue Moon 6,341]

I have read Cupcakes and watched its videos. I don't really hate it or like it. I pretty much just acknowledge its existence. However, there is one fanfic that I hate so much. That would be Sweet Apple Massacre. Eugh.

[Ghost 173]

  I haven't read it and I'm not sure if I want to.  I get the gist of it though, and don't hate the idea of it but don't like it either. I can take some gore depending on the situation, but the thought of Dashie being mutilated doesn't appeal to me, so I think I'll pass. I couldn't even watch the animated version. I've never been a fan of horror/ slasher stuff, but I understand there are people who love it. To each his/ her own, it's just not for me.

[Mand'alor Dash 2,224]

I can't really say I "enjoyed" cupcakes, but I definitely have to give it props for the writing style. Very gross, disturbing imagery and dialogue.

 

I can appreciate a well-written fic, even if it's sick and mean-spirited.

[Castle Bleck 19,356]

The organ-harvesting scene in this story reminds me of a certain main antagonist from the second season of Criminal Minds.

[Zygen 6,066]

Eh I've never read it, I know enough about it though. Me and guts and gore don't typically mix so i'd rather not read it, and I'm not really a horror fan either.

 

I don't really find the appeal in reading about RD being cut to shreds by Pinkie more or less.

 

I'm not really a horror or grimdark person really anyways. I'm ok with somewhat dark stuff, but not really grimdark like cupcakes. They'd probably make me sick reading them to be honest.

[MEMJ0123 33]

Cupcakes was the first fanfic I ever read (I know, what a wonderful 'welcome to the herd' eh?). It didn't bother me, but it didn't sit right with me either. I just found it weird. Oh well, these things will happen. Best we can do is just ignore them. The more hatred we express toward something, the larger a presence it becomes.

[Vedana Purity 221]

A weird, boring, and so bloody terrible that I did not even finish reading it. I mean it makes no sense, there is no reason for why Pinkie Pie did those acts, and its just so damn boring.

 

I mean good lord, the Molestia fanficiton is more entertaining than Cupcake and Rainbow Factory combined.

[WinterFreeze 23]

it was the most horrible thing i have seen and i was scared for a few months and when i here cupcakes at brony con or at my school i scream and run and yell at the person that told it so ya

[EndtheRaven 161]

I was disturbed by it, the thought of rainbow dash losing her wings, and life is horrifying. I mean I respect the genre and all, but when it's applied to ponies it becomes depressing. 

[Lankman 86]

So what do I think of cupcakes, I think it is messed up, pinkie pie ripping out dashies guts and putting them into her cupcakes and I also think it is not scary at all just very disturbing.

 

blood and guts is all this creepypasta is, nothing new.

 

what are your thoughts on it.

[Pinkamena Dianne Pie 465]

I think it was a bit mild, but what do you expect from things dealing with ponies, right?

[Nemesis Atlas 31]

I think it was a little gruesome but it didn't really shock me, unlike Smile HD... wait I'm getting off topic. Anyway, it was kind of interesting (TO READ THAT IS, NOT WHAT PINKIE WAS DOING!) since they were able to use Pinkie's craziness to something much more horrifying. Guts and blood doesn't really make me puke or react, you can see it on almost any horror/thriller movie, and this isn't even worse compared to SmileHD I MEAN... Human Centi I MEAN......... Chainsaw Massacre? But making cupcakes out of it is just plain wrong...

Edited May 20, 2014 by Nemesis Atlas

[Banul 3,831]

I'm not a big fan of all that grimdark stuff. I just seems contrary to what the show is about. If that's what I wanted, I'd go watch a horror movie or something.

[Oblivion 20,266]

I like it, not because of the fact of the gore, but because I like seeing how the ponies would react in such a situation.

[Pinkamena Dianne Pie 465]

I think it was a little gruesome but it didn't really shock me, unlike Smile HD... wait I'm getting off topic. Anyway, it was kind of interesting (TO READ THAT IS, NOT WHAT PINKIE WAS DOING!) since they were able to use Pinkie's craziness to something much more horrifying. Guts and blood doesn't really make me puke or react, you can see it on almost any horror/thriller movie, and this isn't even worse compared to SmileHD I MEAN... Human Centi I MEAN......... Chainsaw Massacre? But making cupcakes out of it is just plain wrong...

When I watched Smile HD for the first time, I was laughing so hard I couldn't breathe. I then showed my best friend the video and he tried beating me up. He eventually gave up after I was dying on the floor from laughing so hard.

[PartyWithPinkie 189]

Cupcakes is very mild compared to some of the other MLP gore fics. Like Cheerilee's Garden or Sweet Apple Massacre (I don't recommend them personally. They're pretty distasteful)

[Hastur 505]

I laughed at it, then I told PinkiePie about it and she gave me a bad look before stuffing a cupcake in my mouth((Pinkie is my imaginary friend/roommate...deal with it))

[SapphireStone 0]

In my opinion, Cupcakes is very poorly written. The gore was, well, gore, and truly disturbing.

[roguesoul 85]

I think Cupcakes is interesting, gory and bloody, but still interesting. I think it has a good dose of horror to it, but the story is well incomplete. But there are fics in the way of gore that are a lot worse than Cupcakes such as a certain Cheerilee's Garden, I would rather read Cupcakes everyday for the rest of my life then read Cheerilee's Garden again. Not that its bad in terms of bad grammer and spelling mistakes, but if your not a fan of Cupcakes, your gonna hate Cheerilee's Garden.

[Discordian 6,015]

I didn't see Pinkie the same for awhile after reading it. It wasn't necessarily scary, shocking or anything I haven't seen before but it still left an impression on me in a way.

 

I had to rewatch the show to reaffirm Pinkie's original concept.

 

I love this video parody of it though:

 

 

The song choice was perfect and it added just a dash of dark comedy in there. I found it highly amusing.

Edited June 1, 2014 by Discordian