S05:E05 - Tanks for the Memories

[AndrewKnapp 121]

Rainbow Dash is my favorite show character, and I thought it was kind of mean when Fluttershy made Dash cry. Now of course, she was already feeling bad, but I think Fluttershy made it worse. Her element is Kindness, but that wasn't exactly Kindness at all.

[Time Shield 402]

Rainbow Dash is my favorite show character, and I thought it was kind of mean when Fluttershy made Dash cry. Now of course, she was already feeling bad, but I think Fluttershy made it worse. Her element is Kindness, but that wasn't exactly Kindness at all.

 

She did it because she knew Rainbow Dash wouldn't be able to accept Tank having to hibernate unless she was forced to face the truth about it.  It's like when she had to force the breezies to leave her home; sometimes kindness can be harsh, but it doesn't make it any less kind in the end.

[EVBP 94]

This episode is a perfect example of why we as fans love this show so much. It's not shallow. It's not just pretty colors. It's sad; it is hard to watch without crying; and it goes way beyond the subject matter of your average cartoon show. Name another cartoon show on Saturday morning that has discussed the Kubler-Ross model. I cry everytime I watch this episode, because I am reminded throughout of the inevitable truth that Rainbow Dash will have to face. I can't say it is perfect, but it is very near it. In my book 10/10!

[BritishBrony2012 825]

There sence that really annoyed me, it where four of the mane 6 end up crying then when Twilight try to calm things Pinkie think she not sad and say Applejack on the inside and Applejack reply with it truth, it annoyed me. Do they want Twilight Sparkle to cry like them to see she sad. Why you need to cry to know you're sad. Applejack do show some tears during the season.

[SteveMorison 407]

This seems to be one of those episodes which is awesome on first viewing and then when the analysis team comes in it turns to shit.

[Shiny 54]

Even Tank is sad about having no milk and cookies

Edited November 29, 2015 by Shiny

[Sketches_The_Unicorn 10]

Tank was sad the he had to leave rainbowdash I can agree with tank... In so many was

[Umbral Noir 1,556]

Really really enjoyed this one, not just because we got to hear a proper Rainbow Dash song, but all the references involved too! "Tanks for the memories", the Grinch face and Twilight's "Winter is Coming" really made this episode a treat to enjoy! The plot in itself was very well done too, quite the emotional rollercoaster. All in all, good work Cindy Morrow!

[SaraEH 398]

I have ONE thing to say !!! RAAINBOWSLIPPERS XD 

[MovieLord101 140]

Btw, I wanna address something about the crying scene. Some fans who don't like this episode get confused as to why Dashie's crying so hard over Tank, as we've hardly seen her play with him since Season 2. However, I think her meltdown at the end was more than just her crying over her pet.

 

Prior to this episode, Dash has been shown to be very stubborn over her emotions. Sure, she gets panicky and upset at times, but we're never actually seen her CRY or deeply sad before. Probably because she doesn't wanna be seen like that as she thinks it would affect other ponies' image of her. For example, we see towards the end of "The Last Roundup" that she's slightly crying but she's quick to try and hide her tears. So, if anything, I think Dashie has a nasty habit of bottling up her sadness and try to hide any ideas that she's scared or depressed (If you've seen Inside Out, the ending to this episode is early similar to the end of THAT movie, too). So her hysterical crying at the end of this episode was everything from not only the events here, but 4 plus seasons prior worth of bottled emotions coming out at once. I'm kinda shocked none else in the Brony community has considered this!

 

That said, let's celebrate 1 year of a fun episode, and give RD a nice big hug:

 

Also, regarding that "Applejack cries on the inside" comment.....

 

*looks towards Applejack whilst holding a bowl of onions and a photo of her parents*

 

YOU'RE NEXT!

Edited April 25, 2016 by MovieLord101

[AndrewKnapp 121]

 

 

Also, regarding that "Applejack cries on the inside" comment..... *looks towards Applejack whilst holding a bowl of onions and a photo of her parents* YOU'RE NEXT!

 

 

HOLY CRAP, THAT'S A MASSIVE APPLEJACK ROAST!!!!

 

Too bad that Applejack's parents are dead. I don't why the show would say something like that. That's just wrong to everyone that likes the show.

[MovieLord101 140]

HOLY CRAP, THAT'S A MASSIVE APPLEJACK ROAST!!!!

 

Too bad that Applejack's parents are dead. I don't why the show would say something like that. That's just wrong to everyone that likes the show.

 

HAVE they said they're dead? Cause that just seems to be fan head cannon next to Scootalo being an alleged orphan (I think Scootaloo DOES have parents, she's just too busy to ever mention them). All we've gotten so far was one like from AJ last season telling Apple Bloom that "Mom and Dad would be proud of you". For all we know, her parents might only be ASSUMED to be dead and might've ended up somewhere else with amnesia. I've seen that kind of plot bit happen on other shows!

Edited April 25, 2016 by MovieLord101

[powerpuff-tsubasa 448]

oh rainbow rainbow.

 

when you learn?

 

JUST JOKING

 

it does feel bad dashie couldnt even see her turtle pet due to the upcoming winter setup

[bluseymoe 258]

Some people's reactions to this episode proves that Rainbow Dash is just too complex and multi-dimensional for them.

 

Even if what she did was wrong, there's a hell of a lot more to consider when it it comes to why she did it, and it sure as hell wasn't just because "she's selfish". There's way more to her than that.

[Thrond 3,263]

I only really find the conflict here compelling if I read way more into it than it actually offers. Has Rainbow Dash had trouble dealing with loss in the past? Is the whole deal that she's never lost anything before? If so, I wish the episode actually addressed it, because while I do recognize and care about Rainbow's close relationship with Tank, having her sabotage the weather factory because Tank is just gonna hibernate for a few months comes across as childish, and it's hard to sympathize with. The ending, where she's bawling and needs her friends to patronizingly calm her down, only emphasizes the feeling of immaturity, and to be quite frank, I think this is way less satisfying than her unflattering depictions in season 6. "Newbie Dash" has its issues, but at least it figured out how to get Rainbow to show legitimate emotion and insecurity without making her feel like she has the mental state of a small child. At least stuff like the "Who's on first?" routine is really funny, although the faces here are really more obnoxious than anything else. 

[IronCaptain19 15]

Why doesn't rainbow dash just go to California, Arizona, Florida or Mexico. It's warm there

[Pixel Stick 927]

12 minutes ago, IronCaptain19 said:

Why doesn't rainbow dash just go to California, Arizona, Florida or Mexico. It's warm there

Dear Princess Celestia: Rainbow Dash just asked me how to get to "California", "Arizona", "Florida" or "Mexico".  She said they're nice and warm during the winter.  I've never heard of these places.  Do you know anything about them?  Your faithful student, Twilight Sparkle.

[GrimGrimoire 4,973]

5 minutes ago, Pixel Stick said:

Dear Princess Celestia: Rainbow Dash just asked me how to get to "California", "Arizona", "Florida" or "Mexico".  She said they're nice and warm during the winter.  I've never heard of these places.  Do you know anything about them?  Your faithful student, Twilight Sparkle.

 

Dear Twilight,

Please accept the enclosed space heater and bottle of sunscreen. Give them with my regards to Rainbow Dash. Tell her to suck it up and use her imagination like the rest of us. Or go to the dragon lands. I understand it is great there this time of year.

Sincerely yours,
Princess Celestia

 

P.S. Don't use any dimension tearing spells to find these places. We know what happened the last time you did it.

[Jeric 46,866]

On 5/3/2017 at 3:59 PM, Pixel Stick said:

Dear Princess Celestia: Rainbow Dash just asked me how to get to "California", "Arizona", "Florida" or "Mexico".  She said they're nice and warm during the winter.  I've never heard of these places.  Do you know anything about them?  Your faithful student, Twilight Sparkle.

 

On 5/3/2017 at 4:10 PM, GrimGrimoire said:

 

Dear Twilight,

Please accept the enclosed space heater and bottle of sunscreen. Give them with my regards to Rainbow Dash. Tell her to suck it up and use her imagination like the rest of us. Or go to the dragon lands. I understand it is great there this time of year.

Sincerely yours,
Princess Celestia

 

P.S. Don't use any dimension tearing spells to find these places. We know what happened the last time you did it.

As the creator of this topic I hereby award you both with this token of my appreciation for your success at making me laugh for a minute straight. 

 

[Larrydog 320]

this is the first episode to really pulled at my heartstrings and I felt very bad for rainbow dash, and I find Rainbow's relationship's with tank to be the cutest thing ever

[Moony the Cat 3,704]

I didnt liked this Episode. I dont care if its supposedly handling the theme of death, it didnt happened in the Episode, so i dont see why i should feel emotional. Instead, her Turtle just had to sleep and she overreacted extreme, putting everyone in danger. Maybe i cant feel sympathy because i have no pets , that could also be the case, but this Episode just made me angry at Rainbow Dash for being selfish again.

[Thrond 3,263]

I honestly think this is up there with "Over a Barrel" as far as messing up serious topics goes. I have zero sympathy for Rainbow being sad her pet hibernates, like a goddamn toddler, and even if this episode were about death, Rainbow's actions would be hard to sympathize with. If this is about grief, it's a completely inept take on the subject matter, to the extent that it makes the show seem less mature. It's like a small child trying to sound grown-up. And even most of the jokes are weak. This sucks. 

The Clear Skies/Open Skies routine is great, though. The song has grown on me, but it's absolutely wasted by the garbage context. Maybe if it were tacked on and didn't reference the actual plot, I'd be able to listen to it on its own, but ugh, no thanks. 

Score:
Entertainment: 4/10
Characters: 2/10
Themes: 4/10
Story: 1/10
Overall: 28/100

[bigbertha 415]

The biggest problem with this episode is the broken metaphor. It tries to act like Tank hibernating is like dying, but those are completely different things. Rainbow Dash just seems so selfish. The episode feels so useless because Tank appears again only 8 episodes later.

Score: 2/10

Edited July 22, 2018 by bigbertha

[Meushell 52]

I didn’t really care for this episode because Rainbow was over the top. Hibernation being a metaphor for death was done much better in Tinker Bell and the Legend of the Neverbeast.

Two highlights though...

“Rainbow Dash, your winter is going to be...(dramatic pause)...pet-less.”

“Waaahhh!”

That was hilarious.

The other highlight was Rainbow and Tank having Tank and Rainbow slippers.

[qwerE 96]

I actually quite liked the episode. It did feel awkward to see Rainbow make a big fuss out of just a hibernation, but I guess it can be hard for somepony. Maybe it was the best the writers could do without making the episode too dark. I actually found the jokes funny because hibernation didn't seem like something devastating to feel sad about.