Would you REALLY date a pony?

[Knightgem 158]

In the end. Date. No, but she would certainly become a pet like friend. Pet in the sense that I'd feed her, groom her and all that good stuff and of course being able to talk to talk. That would be so cool! + I get to buy her stuff and make her look even MORE "fabulous"

[gamecubeguy214 2,512]

Yes, certainly. I say I don't want a girlfriend, which is mostly true, but if it's Rainbow Dash I want it all. Ponies are way more cute than humans, and they are more cuddlable, because that's obviously a word. There's something about ponies that make them more attractive than humans in most ways for me. I'm scared to post this..

[Kings&Hooves14 616]

Yes, definitely; I'm a furry, so sue me.

Besides, a romantic relationship doesn't have to physical. I've never really been interested in the...um...more intimate kind of physical contact.

[RavenholmZombie 1,330]

If the pony who was interested in me was nice, understanding, and willing to accept that I'm not perfect, then sure, I don't see why not.

[Applejacket 185]

I would be ALL OVER Applejack were she to be real <3

[They call me Loyalty 1,948]

Taking into account the terrible moral implications of such an act. I'd say... yes.

[pnylvr 185]

I have no real reason to have a philosophical objection. They may not have human bodies, but their minds are essentially those of adult humans, which is the important thing. They're also prettier than many humans (although that's mostly because physical flaws are optional for animated characters), and certainly in many cases nicer. 

[Storm Striker 35]

I have no idea. I'm leaning a bit on both sides. I mean MLP ponies are sentient animals, just like us. It would be inconcivable if it never happened(Love knows no bounds). Sure if the pony and I knew eachother and somehow got romatically involved but it would also be somewhat awkward and weird. If I was interrogated about it by people, I would become a nervous wreak.   

[Earthenhoof 47]

I'm already halfway there.

[Flutterbattyyy 331]

Oh, of course I would! I don't see anything different with that. They're sapient beings, with human-like abilities. They look physically attractive; and personally, I think they look a whole heck of a lot more attractive than humans do. 

 

As for the difference-in-physical-form argument, I don't see why appearances should be the defining factor anyways. 

 

I would date Fluttershy if I could. Whether I am human of if I become a pony, that wouldn't make a single difference. 

 

 

Of course not, they're animals. I don't care if they talk, they're still animals.

 

By that argument, we're all animals. xD

 

The real line of separation is between sapient beings and non-sapient beings. (Sapient is technically the correct word, but most use the word sentient.) All alien-beings, humans and MLP-ponies included, would be considered sapient.

Yes, certainly. I say I don't want a girlfriend, which is mostly true, but if it's Rainbow Dash I want it all. Ponies are way more cute than humans, and they are more cuddlable, because that's obviously a word. There's something about ponies that make them more attractive than humans in most ways for me. I'm scared to post this..

 

Same here. xD  I'm not interested in humans really, but for Fluttershy (or Twilight or Rainbow Dash), I'd be so down. 

 

Like you said, ponies are way more cute, attractive, and cuddly than humans. I'm being a copycat at this point, haha, but there's just something special about them...

Edited October 26, 2016 by ElementalFluttershee

[heavens-champion 1,905]

Nah. We'd just be friends. We're not even the same species.

[Lillim 45]

I mean a pastel pony... like with legs....like with a mane and tail...like dude if I was a pony then Yus if they where a human then Yus if we where a Equestria girl yeh if they where a pony Ney

[Whirlwind 1,059]

Well.......Yes, but only if I were a pony too.

[Midnight Seashell 206]

Desperate times call for desperate measures so definitely l would and maybe take it to the next level.

[KiraTakahashi 748]

Heck no. But I would become friends with them.

[EmeraldStar04 250]

HECK YEAH! Ponies are cute and I've always wanted to hug one.

[Widdershins 9,960]

Date? Yes, definitely.

If they're every bit as sentient as I am (which is probably the more debatable half of this) and they can carry on a conversation, show as much compassion as any other being could, then yes, I totally see a relationship blossoming.

 

Now, as to a biological perspective...think that's debatable. More likely then not its not the same tools to work with and match up with, but a relationship, even a physical one doesn't have to be based around actual sex. Which is something I think gets glossed over in media these days.

MAN, I wanna bury my face in Pinkie's mane! Who doesn't! Or at least personally feel the muscle & fibers to RD's wings and maybe settle that self-argument if those are feathers or fur.

Really, all I need is someone to show they care.

 

Now if the question was if they were some sort of tentacle-monster-alien, THEN we could get into some deep philosophy there!

[phulusa 16]

Yes, of course I would. What would the problem be, exactly?

[KiraTakahashi 748]

But..the kissing part...animal mouth...so..whyyy

But..the kissing part...animal mouth...so..whyyy

[GrimGrimoire 4,973]

But..the kissing part...animal mouth...so..whyyy

But..the kissing part...animal mouth...so..whyyy

 

I wonder if a (MLP) ponies mouth is cleaner than a humans?

 

I think I posted in this thread before and said nope. But I also think if you truly shared that special connection with one, a lot of people would be more OK with it than they realize.

[KiraTakahashi 748]

I wonder if a (MLP) ponies mouth is cleaner than a humans?

 

I think I posted in this thread before and said nope. But I also think if you truly shared that special connection with one, a lot of people would be more OK with it than they realize.

I suppose. I just can't get over the fact..that they would be an animal. Human form sure that would be fine. Or if I was turned into a pony..I'd still be ok with it.

[Widdershins 9,960]

But..the kissing part...animal mouth...so..whyyy

But..the kissing part...animal mouth...so..whyyy

Well....good lot of men have just as much fur around their mouths as an animal's lips would. Kind of at a loss as to what the difference would be. Sure, dog's mouths, I know where THOSE have been...bleh...can get your point there. Even there, seen quite a few dog owners who will willingly let their dog tongue them when they play "kissies" and what have you.

  Have to think how hilariously painful it'd be to kiss a gryphon. But I imagine ponies are just as careful with their dental hygiene as a human is...despite how it seems to be frequently used as a second set of hands...

[KiraTakahashi 748]

Well....good lot of men have just as much fur around their mouths as an animal's lips would. Kind of at a loss as to what the difference would be. Sure, dog's mouths, I know where THOSE have been...bleh...can get your point there. Even there, seen quite a few dog owners who will willingly let their dog tongue them when they play "kissies" and what have you.

Have to think how hilariously painful it'd be to kiss a gryphon. But I imagine ponies are just as careful with their dental hygiene as a human is...despite how it seems to be frequently used as a second set of hands...

Ugh when people kiss their pets like that it's just gross. I guess I could see your point though.

[Anonymous Old User Who Has Left 599]

Definitely I would. For me, Rarity, Starlight Glimmer, and Luna are hotter than any 17-22 y/o human chicks I'll ever meet.

[Widdershins 9,960]

Ugh when people kiss their pets like that it's just gross. I guess I could see your point though.

Can see yours a bit too. There's a point I suppose everyone has. Horses I see as generally benign creatures, worst you hear is them stomping some human's face in & that's just because they're big creatures. Griffons on the other hand...I'd be hard pressed to see them as anything other then alpha predators. It would be very awkward indeed were I set up on a blind date with Gilda. Part of the reason I find any Gilda romance fanfic to be hilarious, because good luck getting a gryphon gal to NOT tear you in half accidentally! Sharp beak for tearing meat, a ear-bursting roar, TWO types of sharp claws, that beast wasn't meant to be on good relations with any species!