Bad Cosplay!

[cuteycindyhoney 13,283]

All over this forum are threads about people being upset because someone in their life mocked them for being a brony. Now, we have a thread dedicated to mocking people for being a brony. That's not very classy, if you ask me.

[WordplA 42]

We are all such low CLASS people.

 

But are we mocking them for being bronies, or for not having good costuming sense? There's a difference, I think. And besides, I understand that not every costume can be nice and cute. I'm not saying they shouldn't be doing their cosplays or anything hateful like that.

[Stryfe 1]

Well, OP, thank you very much for this. I was having a very bad day up until I saw this thread and the last picture.... Dat mask... just... wow.

[Otter 1,942]

..... no comments

 

 

 

 

To be fair, this guy's hair is pretty cool. Granted, it looks nothing like Rainbow Dash, but oh well... I wouldn't even go so far as to call this a cosplay, it's just a guy in an RD shirt with rainbow-colored hair.

Edited September 24, 2012 by HylianMadness

[Motion Spark 7,806]

To be fair, this guy's hair is pretty cool. Granted, it looks nothing like Rainbow Dash, but oh well... I wouldn't even go so far as to call this a cosplay, it's just a guy in an RD shirt with rainbow-colored hair.

 

you may be right, if this guy just got dressed like that it's fine, but if he dare to call himself a cosplay then, this can be considered a major FAIL!

[BlueStreak 26]

hahahahahahahah that is so wrong on so many levels i cant even describe that horrible stoof but i wanna know where he got those rockin' suspenders.<3

i got that gif from homestuck ( by andrew hussie) when meulin leijon was speaking sign language to kurloz lollolololololol

 

Edited March 8, 2013 by Full Spectrum

[Batbrony 15,994]

Oh gosh, this thread, my sides already hurt... and that third pic in the first post... just... no, just no, I want to unsee so badly, but I can't, I just can't!!!!!!!! Ughhhhh, I feel dirty after seeing that one!!!!!!!

 

Ah, look out, a wild Spike cosplayer!!!!

Well that's just terrifying.

Ya know... that one's actually not half-bad. In fact, it's really pretty good. Kudos!

Edited September 28, 2012 by Batbrony

[dragon4111 914]

OH god Please tell me there is brain bleach somewhere*rummages through my soda bottles*oh son of a. *sighs pitifully*trust fandom to come up with both good and bad cosplays.

[PurplePop 5]

bad cosplays are like friends. at first your like "this is fun!" then it's like "why did i ever do this glubin' stuff!!?!?" (homestuck fans) but then its to late because you already posted it on the internet and you have to deal with your shame for the rest of your life!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! So like i said, friends.

[Solar Wind 595]

Does it have to be ponies? Im have some that ren't ponies...

I now have my rolemodel for life.

No.

 

Ooh lala.

 

I'll never look at Fluttershy the same way... Shes much cuter now.

 

There were also alot where the girls were completely naked cosplayind Derpy... But there was like 15 different pics for that, and I dont want anymore warning points. I just saved it to my HD.

[Claudia Smoles 72]

it's not that hard to find pictures hahaha!!!!

 

this cosplay is so wrong in so many ways I can't describe, the guy can't even fit in a gay parade

 

no no no no no no no no!!!!!!!! nothing really against fat people, but if you're fat, cosplay a fitting character for you! all of them are horrible but the worst is Rarity, my poor Rarity she doesn't deserve this

 

 

..... no comments

 

 

she looks like she's going to a prom, with a really ugly dress so noooo!!!

 

fuck!!! TEH HELLLLL

 

 

THIS FANDOM REALLY HATES RARITY, BECAUSE SHE ALWAYS GETS THE WEIRD COSPLAYERS, THAT'S NOT FAIR!

 

those were pretty cute. Except for the last one :| that's just creepy. I also think the first one of the OP was pretty cute, but the others were.. less cute.

I mean, come on guys, not all of us has a perfect figure and 300 dollars to spare for pony cosplay :|

[PlunderSteed 1,251]

What is this, I don't even? I really don't get the whole horse-head thing. Wigs? Sure. Clever mish-mash of hand-made clothing? That's cool. But horse heads? WTF. I thought the whole appeal of the show was the fact that the characters were very human-like in a lot of ways. It's very weird to see that being turned around and the characters made more animal-like.

[khaine21x3 789]

ROLFCOPTER!

 

I never laughed so hard in my life! those pics are awesome.I don't think that mlp cosplay will work out too well.That chick pulling a cart looks like something out of saint's row 3.

[RainbowDashie 767]

how can you possibly get something like this in a store.

who would ever be in one of these suits and enjoy it? not me anyway.

RARITY NOOOOOOOOO

[GoneForeverBye 184]

Come on, guys. it's just a bunch of people...having...fun...uh...we shouldn't...judge-oh who the hell am I kidding? :< Someone please hand me the "unsee" button. I really need it.

 

...the unimaginable horrors of cosplay...

[5guysburgersnfries 216]

--------------------

Edited November 13, 2022 by 5guysburgersnfries

[GoneForeverBye 184]

So I want to contribute to this thread, so I type in "terrible mlp cosplay" on Google. The results which I do get are actually decent cosplayers...

 

Thanks Google! Really helpful there! ...okay, let's see...

 

Oh. It turned out I forgot to add the "terrible" to the search bar. My eyes are burning and guessing from the fact I can still remember the cosplay pics in this thread, nobody handed me an "unsee" button. :C

 

 

Well, not the best I could come up with, but still pretty ridiculous in my eyes...

 

 

Ah, this is more like it.

 

 

 

You know how diabolical I feel now? Yeah.

 

---

 

If you cannot see the last picture, then... dunno, too bad? But it's almost purposefully done to be as terrible as possible...

 

Okay, so apparently taking the picture on Google itself, where it can be seen even after being deleted, apparently doesn't work.

 

EDIT: Hahah! I just took the google version and re uploaded it permanently somewhere else!

 

Edited October 20, 2012 by OlegEqualzName

[StingeMuffin 244]

RARITY NOOOOOOOOO

 

I think these are pretty good, compared to some of the other pictures posted so far (the second picture of the original post... that man RD has the "I know I'm sexy" look in his face XD). The wigs and clothes are fitting for each character (and the Pinkie Pie cosplayer's hair looks gorgeous ), but the Rarity cosplayer's size does detract from her overall appearance. I still like her more than the RD cosplayer.

[Motion Spark 7,806]

those were pretty cute. Except for the last one :| that's just creepy. I also think the first one of the OP was pretty cute, but the others were.. less cute. I mean, come on guys, not all of us has a perfect figure and 300 dollars to spare for pony cosplay :|

it's a matter of tastes, to me all of them are pretty awful because they don't do justice to the character and some of the costumes were really simple.

[Claudia Smoles 72]

it's a matter of tastes, to me all of them are pretty awful because they don't do justice to the character and some of the costumes were really simple.

 

I guess you are right. I just find it funny these people just cosplay anyway. But indeed, some were pretty awful...

(I love your signature, by the way! <3)

[Burning Desire 11]

It seems like some people are judging costumes based on whether they find the person in the costume attractive or not, which is dumb. There are a few costumes that have been posted which are legitimately frightening and ridiculous XD but really, get real here people. Most of the costumes posted aren't bad at all. Many are cool, and imaginative, and a few are really funny (in an intentional way, I think). So far this is more of a "Decent Cosplay (with some nightmare fuel thrown in)" thread than a "bad cosplay" thread.

[BlueStreak 26]

Does it have to be ponies? Im have some that ren't ponies...

I now have my rolemodel for life.

No.

 

Ooh lala.

 

I'll never look at Fluttershy the same way... Shes much cuter now.

 

There were also alot where the girls were completely naked cosplayind Derpy... But there was like 15 different pics for that, and I dont want anymore warning points. I just saved it to my HD.

 

holy shoot these are very ugly bad cosplay! i know that if someone on the forums did this id feel pretty dang bad, because if any of you know me personally (RedBalistic & PurplePop the coolset peeps efurr!) you know that i am a pretty big cup of soft pudding...

[Acrylic Swirl 3]

 

 

I think these are pretty good, compared to some of the other pictures posted so far (the second picture of the original post... that man RD has the "I know I'm sexy" look in his face XD). The wigs and clothes are fitting for each character (and the Pinkie Pie cosplayer's hair looks gorgeous ), but the Rarity cosplayer's size does detract from her overall appearance. I still like her more than the RD cosplayer.

 

I agree, I don't think that Rarity Cosplayer's size really takes away from the appearance. I've never cosplayed myself, but these turned out pretty good... Pinkie. Is. Adorable.

[The Rainbownator 42]

Oh lu...I mean oh celestial why oh why oh the horror the horror although the first one was alright but still THE HORROR oh god the horror

[Dr. Frasier Crane 319]

Why...whywhywhywhy do they insist on wearing those freaky realistic horse masks? D:

It just doesn't look right... Especially that 3rd pic of that person cosplaying Rainbow Dash... Scarred for life.