Recast MLP with members from the forums

[Twisted Cyclone 🚓 6,221]

I debated whether to put this here or in the forum games but I thought it'd be more fitting here.

I remember seeing a thread similar to this using the Mane 6 so I broaden it a bit to include ALL ponies. Just for fun, if you were able to recast My Little Pony with members from here on the forums, who would you choose? You can't choose yourself. lol

Rainbow Dash - @Lucky Bolt

Pinkie Pie - @Gone Airbourne

Rarity - @PiratePony

Twilight Sparkle - @SparklingSwirls

Soarin' - @Deae Rising Shine~

Fluttershy - @Fluttershy Friend

[Sparklefan1234 161,874]

Rainbow Dash: @Captain Clark

Pinkie Pie:           @ChB

Fluttershy:               @Fluttershy Friend

Twilight Sparkle: @Sunset Rose

Big Macintosh:       @Celli

Princess Celestia: @Valencia

Princess Luna:    @Lunalicious Alexshy

Rarity:                       @PiratePony

Lyra Heartstrings:  @Totally Lyra

Applejack:             @Princess Aurora Wolf

Minuette:                @SparklingSwirls

Sunset Shimmer:   @Ganondorf8

 Discord:                @Mesmelicious Rize

Maud Pie:            @Maudileena

Thorax:               @WiiGuy2014

Windy Whistles: @Windy Whistles

Sci-Twi:              @Nightfallicious Gloamiscus

DJ Pon3:           @.Wolfe.

Starlight Glimmer: @ShootingStar159

Princess Cadance: @Lunar Echo

The Smooze: @The_Gobo

Chief Thunderhooves: @Dark Qiviut

Ahuizotl:                     @ShadOBabe

The deer from the opening of Equestria Girls: Legend of Everfree: @PathfinderCS 

Edited January 20, 2018 by Sparklefan1234

[Lore Finder 74]

Indent know y'all that wel so I couldn't say but I'd have to say id be a background pony who doesn't even show up most of the time.

[Prospekt 10,984]

Rainbow Dash - @Lucky Bolt

Pinkie Pie - @Kyoshi

Fluttershy - @Fluttershy Friend

Twilight Sparkle - @Sparklefan1234

Rarity - @Jeric

Applejack - @Princess Aurora Wolf

Discord - @Mesmelicious Rize

Flash Sentry - @Stardust Balance

Princess Celestia - @Valencia

Princess Luna - @Lunalicious Alexshy

Spike - @ChB

Trixie - @Stormfury

Starlight Glimmer - @SparklingSwirls

Big Macintosh - @Twisted Cyclone

Thorax - @WiiGuy2014

Lyra - @Totally Lyra

Derpy - @Batbrony

[Stardust Balance 7,716]

10 minutes ago, Prospekt said:

 

Flash Sentry - @Stardust Balance

 

*Nostrils flare, heavy breathing.*

...Whatever, I'd make a better Sentry for having a personality anyway.

[Wannabrony 11,638]

Rainbow Dash - @Trotteur Sauvage (He goes from thread to thread so fast...)

Pinkie  - @KashikoiPai

Rarity - @Nye

Twilight - @Duality

Fluttershy - @Fluttershy Friend

Applejack - @pples (i have no idea)

Starlight - @Nightfallicious Gloamiscus

 

[Nightfall Gloam 18,237]

Rainbow Dash: @Lucky Bolt

Pinkie Pie: @SparklingSwirls

Rarity: @Trotteur Sauvage

Twilight: @Deae Rising Shine~

Fluttershy: @Fluttershy Friend

Applejack: @Twisted Cyclone

Starlight Glimmer: @Jade Fire

[Fluttershy Friend 25,445]

Thanks friends! I feel really hmm appreciated ? (I don't know if it is the best word in this case).

And what about with for example Derpy, Starlight, Spike, Cadence, Chrysalis?

 

[The Kaeya Simp 13,968]

27 minutes ago, Stardust Balance said:

*Nostrils flare, heavy breathing.*

...Whatever, I'd make a better Sentry for having a personality anyway.

I'd make the best sentry .]

*Nostrils flare, heavy breathing.* she my waifu

Edited January 19, 2018 by Sherbert Music-Guard

[Will Guide 21,325]

25 minutes ago, Prospekt said:

Rainbow Dash - @Lucky Bolt

Pinkie Pie - @Kyoshi

Fluttershy - @Fluttershy Friend

Twilight Sparkle - @Sparklefan1234

Rarity - @Jeric

Applejack - @Princess Aurora Wolf

Discord - @Mesmelicious Rize

Flash Sentry - @Stardust Balance

Princess Celestia - @Valencia

Princess Luna - @Lunalicious Alexshy

Spike - @ChB

Trixie - @Stormfury

Starlight Glimmer - @SparklingSwirls

Big Macintosh - @Twisted Cyclone

Thorax - @WiiGuy2014

Lyra - @Totally Lyra

Derpy - @Batbrony

I agree with most of these picks, especially @Mesmelicious Rize being Discord what with similarities like this:

Wouldn't you agree, @Mesmelicious Rize?

[The Kaeya Simp 13,968]

@WiiGuy2014 = King Thorax

[Will Guide 21,325]

If @Northern Light Flyercomes back with Baby Dashie, I think the Baby would make a wonderful Flurry Heart. Wouldn't you agree?

[The Kaeya Simp 13,968]

2 minutes ago, WiiGuy2014 said:

If @Northern Light Flyercomes back with Baby Dashie, I think the Baby would make a wonderful Flurry Heart. Wouldn't you agree?

yeah, baby dashie = McFlurry heart

[ShadOBabe 18,984]

@PathfinderCS as Sombra.

Playing against type is more fun. XD

[Batbrony 15,994]

1 hour ago, Prospekt said:

Derpy - @Batbrony

When you see that you're Derpy...

[Will Guide 21,325]

Oh yeah and @ShadOBabe could be Ahuizotl.

[Prospekt 10,984]

2 minutes ago, ShadOBabe said:

@PathfinderCS as Sombra.

Playing against type is more fun. XD

Kinda like how I picked this one. It's a joke because Stardust's OC (of the same name) is supposed to be paired with Twilight and, in a way, competing with Flash (whom Stardust really doesn't like...)

1 hour ago, Prospekt said:

Flash Sentry - @Stardust Balance

 

[ShadOBabe 18,984]

19 minutes ago, WiiGuy2014 said:

Oh yeah and @ShadOBabe could be Ahuizotl.

ShadOZotl: Hola ponies!! Prepare to meet your DOOM!! MUWAHAHAHAHA!!

Edited January 19, 2018 by ShadOBabe

[ChB 18,532]

@Prospekt Why am I Spike?

[Prospekt 10,984]

1 hour ago, Prospekt said:

Rainbow Dash - @Lucky Bolt

Pinkie Pie - @Kyoshi

Fluttershy - @Fluttershy Friend

Twilight Sparkle - @Sparklefan1234

Rarity - @Jeric

Applejack - @Princess Aurora Wolf

Discord - @Mesmelicious Rize

Flash Sentry - @Stardust Balance

Princess Celestia - @Valencia

Princess Luna - @Lunalicious Alexshy

Spike - @ChB

Trixie - @Stormfury

Starlight Glimmer - @SparklingSwirls

Big Macintosh - @Twisted Cyclone

Thorax - @WiiGuy2014

Lyra - @Totally Lyra

Derpy - @Batbrony

I have some to add! 

Apple Bloom - @SolarFlare13

Philomena - @Qrow Branwen, because their previous display name was Ph0enix

Spitfire - @Meson Bolt

Scootaloo - @Sherbert Music-Guard

Princess Cadance - @PinkuRiku (I miss you! )

Shining Armor - @Duality

Sunset Shimmer - @Nightfallicious Gloamiscus

1 minute ago, ChB said:

@Prospekt Why am I Spike?

It was tough to choose Pinkie Pie but I finally settled on @Kyoshi. I figured you would still be suitable for a character who is generally positive, optimistic, and loyal. So, I matched you with Spike.

[ChB 18,532]

3 minutes ago, Prospekt said:

It was tough to choose Pinkie Pie but I finally settled on @Kyoshi. I figured you would still be suitable for a character who is generally positive, optimistic, and loyal. So, I matched you with Spike.

Thanks, Prospekt!  

[Twisted Cyclone 🚓 6,221]

2 hours ago, Prospekt said:

Big Macintosh - @Twisted Cyclone

 

I'm curious (even though I totally can see it) but what's your reasoning behind choosing me for Big Macintosh?

[Prospekt 10,984]

Just now, Twisted Cyclone said:

I'm curious (even though I totally can see it) but what's your reasoning behind choosing me for Big Macintosh?

Really just the OC, which makes me think of a blue pegasus Big Macintosh. I considered you for Applejack as well, mostly for the same reason.

[Lore Finder 74]

@The_Gobo as daring do. I don't know why. It just seems like a good idea.

Hey guys'll! What's the closest thing MLP has to an eldritch abomination!?

[Prospekt 10,984]

2 minutes ago, Lore Finder said:

@The_Gobo as daring do. I don't know why. It just seems like a good idea.

Hey guys'll! What's the closest thing MLP has to an eldritch abomination!?

I think @The_Gobo would make a good Smooze.